For the ninth week, the fans were able to vote online on a selection for each of the rockers to do. Given multiple choices of several songs done previously by each rocker or of a "wildcard" pick of a song done earlier by another contestant, the fans selected Marty's "wildcard" which was the Foo Fighters' "Everlong."

By special permission, MartyCasey.org has been given a scan of the sheet music autographed by Marty and the back of the music where he wrote out the song lyrics.